CHOOSING THE PERFECT STARTER KNIFE

Our first grandchild, a precious baby girl named Ollie, was born a few days ago. Being the avid knife collector and user that I am, I’ve had her first couple of knives picked out for months already. Every knife person I know has looked forward to gifting the youngsters in their life with their first knives. While I’m sure that the same could be said of those who are passionate about virtually any hobby, the name of the magazine is Knives Illustrated, not Action Figures Monthly or Baseball Card Digest. So, let’s talk first knives.

ARE THEY READY?

A common question bandied about in various online forums and social media sites is some variation of, “How old should a child be before they get their first knife?” The thing is, there really isn’t a hard and fast rule for this. It isn’t like being able to get a license to drive or being allowed to buy a beer at the local pub. There’s a saying people like to toss around when they’re aging but don’t want feel old: “Age is just a number.” That applies here as well. Just because a child turns a certain age doesn’t automatically mean they’re ready for their very own blade.

FIXED OR FOLDER?

In speaking with other knife aficionados, most of them recall receiving a folding knife, as opposed to a fixed blade, for their first knife when they were growing up. Further, most of them felt that a folding knife was a good place to start for a young person.

Sure, a very valid argument can be made in favor of a sheath knife, such as the lack of moving parts and the general durability. However, in this day and age, most young people would be better off carrying a folding knife, something that can ride deep in the pocket and that won’t cause alarm if it is seen by an adult. Thus, folders will be the focus of our discussion.

Remember, too, that times have changed. When I was growing up in the 1970s and 1980s, most guys I knew carried a pocketknife, often either a Buck 110 or a Swiss Army Knife of some sort. Today, even that lowly SAK could mean a suspension or possible expulsion from school, as it would be considered to be a weapon.

There are a couple of things to consider when you’re deciding whether they’re ready for their first knife.

“What it boils down to is whether the child is able to follow basic instructions as well as develop at least the beginnings of good safety habits.”

MATURITY

This is very subjective, but it is a key element in the decision. It isn’t ruled by age, gender, or education. Maturity is, at the core, a level of development that governs how a person responds to a situation. I mean, I’ve met exceptionally mature 5-year-olds whom I could trust with any tool they’re able to hold, and I’ve known guys in their forties who probably shouldn’t be allowed to use a spoon unsupervised and without a helmet.

What it boils down to is whether the child is able to follow basic instructions as well as develop at least the beginnings of good safety habits. Here are a few questions to consider:

• Do they understand that the knife is a tool, not a toy?
• Do they grasp the importance of keeping a folding knife closed when it isn’t in use?
• Can they be trusted not to run with a knife?

This doesn’t mean that they’ll never make bad decisions. Many of us can probably recall carving or cutting something we shouldn’t have when we were younger. This may have also included a few rounds of what was simply referred to as “the knife game,” where you’d splay your fingers out on a table and use your knife to stab back and forth at the spaces between your fingers, trying to go as fast as you can. However, as a general guideline, the more mature the youth is, the more responsible they’ll be with their new knife.

PHYSICAL CAPABILITIES

Just as you need to consider their maturity and intellect, you need to take into account the physical side of the equation. Start with the size of their hands. Are they going to be capable of holding and safely using the knife you intend to give them? If the handle is too large, the knife will be awkward and cumbersome, creating a risk of accident or injury. It’s the same for grown-ups; if a knife isn’t comfortable to hold and use, we’ll find reasons not to carry it, which defeats the whole purpose.

Along with hand size is dexterity. If it has a liner lock, will they be able to safely disengage it? If it has a flipper opening, will they be able to operate it? While there’s bound to be some degree of a learning curve with a new knife, you don’t want to put their fingers in danger because they struggle with opening and closing the knife.

The length of the blade is a factor, too. Even a well-balanced knife can feel clumsy if the blade is too long for the task at hand. This is even more apparent when you’re new to using knives and haven’t developed your skills yet. The last thing you want to do is to handicap the child by saddling them with a knife that’s ill-suited for them.

KNIFE SELECTION

Endless options on the market are perfectly suitable for a young person’s first knife. Personally, I tend to favor slip joint models for this momentous occasion (with one lock-back exception that we’ll get to shortly). It is a classic design that isn’t complicated by bells and whistles. While many of us are fond of autos or assisted-open knives, they’re truly unnecessary for a first-time user.

Plus, those sorts of features add to the price tag, which brings us to another consideration—cost. It can be something of a fine line, in that you want to give them a good quality knife, but there’s a fair-to-middling chance that the knife is going to get damaged or lost at some point. After all, just as with grown-up people, even the most responsible kids can have a bad day. While price is somewhat subjective in that what one person feels is fairly inexpensive another might think of as costly, as a general rule I think keeping it under 50 bucks is reasonable.

RECOMMENDATIONS

I often suggest a handful of knives to parents who want to gift one to their sons or daughters. These aren’t the only options out there, of course, and there are probably another dozen or so that are popular choices.

SWISS ARMY KNIFE: HIKER

You can choose from dozens of Victorinox knives, but I favor the Hiker in most cases. It has 13 tools on board, including a wood saw that actually works fairly well. This is an excellent choice for a child who will be spending a good amount of time outdoors. The size is perfect for smaller hands, and the tools are easy to open and close. It is available in classic red just about everywhere, but if you wanted to splurge on a more colorful pattern, you can find exclusive models at DLT Trading.
$32.99  •  Victorinox.com

TL-29

Sometimes referred to as an electrician’s knife, the TL-29 is slightly lesser known than the Swiss Army Knife lineup, but it is no less useful. It has just two tools: a single-edge spearpoint blade and a stripper/screwdriver that can also function as a pretty decent, small pry bar. It is an average-sized pocketknife, so it won’t be cumbersome for younger users. The downside is that it isn’t currently being manufactured, so you’ll have to turn to the used market, such as eBay, to find one. However, they aren’t rare at all and a quick search found a few that were listed for under 10 bucks.
Price varies  •  Ebay.com

“The gift of a knife to a son, daughter, nephew, niece, or other loved one is a special occasion, and carries with it some responsibility.”

BUCK 110

This is the lock-back exception I mentioned earlier. The Buck 110 is a truly classic knife, and it was the first real knife for an untold number of people over the last several generations. However, it is on the larger side, and that needs to be taken into account. It isn’t the best option for smaller hands. But, even if it isn’t their first knife, the Buck 110 deserves a spot in every knife user’s collection.
$59.99  •  BuckKnives.com

SPECIAL MOMENT

The gift of a knife to a son, daughter, nephew, niece, or other loved one is a special occasion and carries with it some responsibility. Take the time to consider the options available and make sure that you’re not only giving them a knife at the right time of their life, but also that you choose a knife that’s well-suited to them.

One final suggestion: Be sure to speak with the parents before giving the child a knife. While you might feel that young boy or girl is certainly ready for the responsibility of knife ownership and use, Mom and Dad make the final call. Yes, they even have veto power over a grandparent.

---

SAFETY AND MAINTENANCE

Handing a child a gift-wrapped box containing the blade you’ve chosen for them is the easy part. Teach them how to sharpen the edge and how to oil it to prevent corrosion, as well as how to clean it as needed.

Safety is also an important topic to cover. Explain the Triangle of Death, which is the area defined by knee to crotch to opposite knee, and how it contains major blood vessels that, if cut, can be deadly. That being the case, knives shouldn’t be used near them. Other basic safety protocols to be discussed include:

• When handing an open knife to someone, it is best to set it down on a stationary object, such as a tabletop, and let them pick it up from there.
• Don’t brace the material being cut on your body. Put it on a log or some other surface. If the knife slips, you don’t want it cutting you.
• Avoid using undue pressure to make a cut. The harder you push, the greater the likelihood that you’ll lose control of the knife.
• Always cut away from your body, but be aware of your surroundings so you’re not cutting toward someone else in your immediate vicinity.

---

Editor’s Note: A version of this article appeared in TREAD Mar/Apr 2024.